Canadian Grand Prix Review

Victory in the wet for MS


Back to
Reject CENTRALE
Back to
Year 2000 Index

Well, can anyone stop the hot Schu shuffle this year? If the Canadian GP is any indication of how the rest of this season will pan out, then it looks as though nothing will stop the Maranello juggernaut prancing its way to both titles. Thankfully, for McLaren fans out there, the Circuit Gilles Villeneuve has a habit of throwing up oddball results, and though Ron Dennis' men have the job ahead of them, it isn't a hopeless situation yet.

Nothing too special about qualifying. BAR were going extremely well, as they seem to do on low downforce tracks. I expected the Arrows to be slightly higher up on the grid, given their straight-line speed advantage, while it was good to see Johnny Herbert in the Jaguar crack the top half. The same could not be said for Eddie Irvine, recording his lowest ever grid spot in F1, narrowly eclipsing his 17th in France last year. The other paddock talking point, it seemed, was Jos Verstappen's new helmet design, in honour of a valiant Dutch national soccer team competing in Euro 2000.

Williams were struggling all weekend, unable to get the balance right, and it showed in lacklustre performances from both Ralf Schumacher and Jenson Button. Up the front, a fascinating duel between Michael Schumacher and David Coulthard for top spot, resolved in the German's favour, but only just. I'll have more to say about Coulthard later.

After qualifying, Irvine went on to comment that Jaguar had ironed out their clutch problems, and they could begin taking advantage of starts just like the BAR boys did. Well, Eddie was half right. While he stalled on the grid, losing two laps (and his race would only get worse after that), not for the first time this year Jacques Villeneuve made a dynamite start to catapult himself up to 3rd. Shades of Imola this year, and Barcelona last year. Funny how Rubens Barrichello couldn't hide his suspicions in the post-race press conference.

Why Mika Hakkinen was quite so tentative going into the first corner I have no idea, but he effectively boxed in Barrichello and let Villeneuve through. And while Canadian fans were smiling, what happened next was utterly predictable. With Schumacher and Coulthard steaming off into the distance, we had the sight, once again, of a BAR holding up faster cars (remember Silverstone this year). No doubting that Barrichello and Hakkinen were much faster. But it was amusing to see Pedro de la Rosa aggressively tacking onto the back of this train in his very-light-on-fuel Arrows, and really putting pressure on the McLaren.

It looked good, but of course it was a false battle. Villeneuve was never meant to be there (I'm not saying he didn't have the right), and Martin Brundle in ITV commentary summed it up when he said Villeneuve was being a "nuisance". Murray Walker, sounding about twice as hyped as he usually does, declared the battle "real motor racing". Was he kidding? Far out, it was more like a case of "real Mosley crappy regulations". It would have been much better to see Barrichello and Hakkinen make it a four-horse race up front (or three-horse, counting Ferrari team orders).

Instead, we got a two-horse race, with Coulthard keeping Schumacher very honest indeed, but that quickly came to naught when Coulthard was penalised. The rules are the rules, what could you do about it? Good ol' Murray, now getting really emotional, declared it an "injustice". Quaint then to see how Brundle, one of Coulthard's managers, declared it "total justice". But bad news for an entertaining race nonetheless.

Thankfully, Barrichello managed to find a way past the BAR. It was a top-notch move, against one of the hardest, meanest racers in the business, from a guy who on the other hand is usually regarded as a bit of a soft touch. Nice to see Barrichello then crank out some brilliant laps just to prove the point. I think both BAR drivers must have been working their tyres very hard in the early stages, because not only did Villeneuve have to concede to Barrichello and Hakkinen, but Ricardo Zonta was also dropping back.

This race was now getting static. Schumacher was almost a full pit-stop ahead of Barrichello, and looking good. Coulthard was trapped in the midfield (read more "real Mosley crappy regulations") and of course had a spin when a few drops of rain (and a Jordan's oil) fell. Both Prosts saw more action in the pit lane than on the track. Rather appropriate, that. And then Heinz-Harald Frentzen dropped out because he didn't like his Jordan's brakes. A la Damon Hill last year (although admittedly I think Frentzen's problem was more terminal).

It took the rain to really inject life back into this race. And also to catapult Giancarlo Fisichella out of nowhere onto the podium. Montreal is traditionally his best race of the year, but he really wasn't on the pace this time, but making his fuel stop at the same time as changing onto wets was a masterstroke, while everyone else had to make extra stops. That he didn't particularly deserve to be quite so high was evidenced by his half-a-dozen off-road excursions after that. Though not quite as many as Irvine! I get a feeling Eddie was really embarrassed after the race - he called his experience like driving "a skateboard".

In fact, I think it's something to do with the Montreal track surface that just about everyone had some nasty moments. The one who was adapting best, no doubt, was Jos Verstappen. In the wet, Jos really was the boss. He was too ragged at the Nurburgring, but here he mixed aggression with control perfectly, and pulled some excellent moves on Alexander Wurz and Trulli. A very well-deserved 5th place finish in the end.

The same level of skill could not be said for a few others. Pedro Diniz resorted to the primeval blinkered style that epitomised his early years by running his namesake De la Rosa off the track. Coulthard got desperate with Wurz, and the Austrian came off second best. But the prize for the ultimate kamikaze was Villeneuve's shocker on Ralf Schumacher at the hairpin. Talk about brain fade! That's the sort of late-braking mayhem you normally see on Grand Prix 2. I don't think Ralf, bung leg and all, particularly wanted a thump like that.

And so Schumi recorded another fairly comfortable victory, slowing down enough to let Barrichello catch up. A fine Ferrari 1-2 that was never really in doubt after Coulthard's penalty. Now they just have to maintain their reliability. If they can do that, I can't see either McLaren driver beating Schumacher, though McLaren is still in the constructors' race, I feel. And, from the press-conference after the race, when Schumacher did a Hakkinen and started thanking all and sundry, I anticipate a Barrichello victory later in the season when Schumi has the title sewn up. Michael suggested as much.

What's up with Hakkinen these days? This was his quietest weekend since late 1997, reduced to also-ran status by Coulthard. Anyone who's read these reviews will know I'm not a great Hakkinen fan, but his lack of form in the last two races has been worrying. On the other hand, I'm so pleased to see Coulthard re-emerge as a front-line challenger, though the cards didn't fall his way in this race.

Memories are too short in F1. Let's not forget that Coulthard was so impressive when he stepped into the breach left by Ayrton Senna in 1994, and that for much of 1995 he outpaced Damon Hill. He then was the equal of Hakkinen in 1996 and 1997, and on occasions put in sparkling weekends. He, more than Mika I feel, did the rebuilding work at McLaren that Hakkinen took full advantage of in 1998 and 1999, leaving David in his dust. I felt that Coulthard was on the up this year, and he's proving that to be true. Let's also not forget the ill-effects of his plane crash. If Coulthard can run Schumi close this year, the whole F1 paddock will be pretty happy.

No team seems to want to fill the gap as 'best of the rest'. On paper, you'd say Jordan. On sheer consistency, you'd say Benetton. On the ability to score points (though they haven't done it in the last few races), you'd say Williams. On nuisance value, you'd say BAR. On sheer team dynamism, you might even be tempted to say Arrows. There is so little between these teams. One team has a good weekend for a particular reason, while another will have a shocker. It'll then be reversed for the next race. And a tweak in set-ups will then see cars like the Saubers, Prosts and Jaguars thrust right into the equation. It's all very hard to analyse.

Some quick comments, nonetheless. Jordan's reliability woes seem to be continuing, and speed-wise they're still well deficient. When Eddie Jordan says in public that he's looking for a works engine next year, it sounds like he's given 2000 up. Benetton seem to be moving forward as a collective unit, but in the dry, on a track where I expected them to shine, they were still off the pace. Conversely, the Williams car seems to be overly sensitive to changing track configurations, and the Grove boys need to find some consistency in this area.

BAR look like they will do well in the next few races where downforce isn't as great a requirement. I look forward to seeing how well they do at Hockenheim. As for Arrows, they continue to surprise, and are really putting the cat amongst the pigeons from time to time. If BAR look good for Hockenheim, with their balanced aerodynamic package how good will Arrows be!

As for the others, Sauber and Minardi continue to stand still, while Prost seems to be making agonisingly slow progress, but some progress nonetheless. Jaguar, though, appear to have absolutely no momentum whatsoever, lurching from one weekend to the next. There's an inherent problem there, and for the life of me I can't really see why there should be.

So, onto France, a character-less track that usually gives a clear indication of where teams rank. On history alone, Ferrari might have a slight advantage over McLaren, but I won't read much into that. For me, the most interesting thing at Magny Cours will not be whether anyone can catch Michael Schumacher, but to see if Coulthard can really establish himself as McLaren's main man.



F1 Rejects
Back to Reject CENTRALE
Main Page   |    Drivers Index   |   Reject Teams   |   Hall of Shame
Featured Rejects
Reject Statistics
Submit-a-Reject
FAQ / Copyright
Reject CENTRALE
• Latest GP Review
• Other Articles
• Links / Banner
Sign Guestbook
Read Guestbook
Current Poll
Previous Polls
All original content Copyright © 1999-2000 Formula One Rejects.