2003 Top 12 Drivers Review

Alonsoda MattaFerrariRaikkonen

An in-depth look at the past season, team by team and driver by driver

Back to
2003 Season Review
Back to
Reject CENTRALE
Go to
Text-Only Version
1. Fernando Alonso
2. Kimi Raikkonen
3. Juan Pablo Montoya
4. Michael Schumacher
5. Mark Webber
6. Jenson Button
7. Rubens Barrichello
8. Ralf Schumacher
9. Cristiano da Matta
10. Jarno Trulli
11. David Coulthard
12. Olivier Panis

1. Fernando Alonso
With only four podium finishes all season, our choice of the Spaniard as driver of the year may raise a few eyebrows. One has to remember, though, that this was Alonso's first season of regular racing after only sitting out 2002 as Renault tester. Plus this year he was driving a car that was decidedly down on power. In view of that, the way in which he charged to the absolute limit on race days, whilst hardly ever going it, was one of the most exciting aspects of 2003. It not only netted him 55 points from eleven points finishes, but also comparisons with the late, great Ayrton Senna.

Without his five retirements, none his fault, he may have been 4th in the title. Highlights were of course his maiden pole and 3rd place in Malaysia where he was suffering from a cold, and his dominant pole and victory in Hungary. But arguably his effort in Spain where he drove at eleven tenths and pressured Michael Schumacher all the way, and in Canada where he clung to the top three despite his engine, best epitomised his season. Not a perfect season by any means - his Saturday qualifying errors in Austria and Italy, plus a ragged race at Monza showed that - but no driver was more impressive in 2003.

Back to the top.
Points:  55 Prospects for 2004:

With such a brilliant season comes the weight of expectation in 2004 as more wins and podiums are anticipated. But with several top engineers leaving Renault and the unknown quantity of a new engine, he will still have to work hard and keep pushing the envelope of his ability if he is to hang on to the top three teams.

WDC:  6th

Our Rating:  9.0
2. Kimi Raikkonen
Many people will have chosen the young Finn as the driver of the year, and it is not difficult to see why. Only three retirements, 13 points-scoring finishes, 10 podiums and his maiden victory were sensational achievements in only his third season of F1, in a car that was not as state-of-the-art as his rivals'. Taking advantage of the new points system that rewarded consistency, he was in title contention right to the end, and were it not for his retirement from a dominant position at the Nurburgring, and his collision with Ralf Schumacher and Barrichello at Hockenheim, he may have snatched the crown.

Nevertheless, there were two factors in particular that kept The Iceman away from the top spot in our books. One was that he still made the odd error at crucial times, in particular his Saturday qualifying mishaps in Australia, Spain and Canada, and his pit-lane speeding offence (albeit a tiny one only) in Melbourne. The other was that, although he collected a swag of points in a manner which had some comparing him to Alain Prost, at times he seemed content to drive for points and wait for the championship to come back to him, rather than grabbing races and the title by the scruff of the neck.

Back to the top.
Points:  91 Prospects for 2004:

With the MP4/19 McLaren already testing and setting rapid times, and with Kimi having gained a decisive edge over team-mate Coulthard, he ought to go into 2004 as championship favourite. He will also be keen to firmly establish himself in his team's affections before the feisty but endearing Montoya joins him in 2005.

WDC:  2nd

Our Rating:  9.0
3. Juan Pablo Montoya
2003 was potentially the year that JPM came of age as a Grand Prix driver. After a disappointing 2002 when he nabbed seven poles but zero wins, he learnt his lesson, recognising that Sunday was what mattered. The result? The Colombian finished this season with only one pole but two wins, as many as anyone else other than Schumi, and a bag of points that had him deep in the championship mix. Particularly noteworthy was of course that streak of eight-straight podiums from Monaco to Italy, and his wins in Monaco and Germany were right out of the top drawer.

Indeed, to sum up how good Montoya's season was, if several things had gone his way, he would have been in a position to win the title. He was punted by Pizzonia in Malaysia, retired from the lead in Austria, and may have won in Japan were it not for an hydraulic failure. But on the demerit side, he also contributed to his own downfall, spinning away the victory in Melbourne, also going off in Canada and Hungary, and needlessly colliding with Barrichello and deservedly earning a drive-through at Indy. At no time did he ever seem to be only coasting, but these mistakes showed he could still go over the limit.

Back to the top.
Points:  82 Prospects for 2004:

How JPM fares in 2004 will be one of the most intriguing questions next year. How well he will work with his team knowing that he's off to McLaren in 2005 remains to be seen. The racer's mentality inherent in JPM and Williams suggests that he will still be a title contender, but one can't help but feel that there will be some tension.

WDC:  3rd

Our Rating:  8.0
4. Michael Schumacher
If the new rules in 2003 were designed to place more pressure on the drivers, then it came as a surprise that one of the big guns least able to respond was Michael Schumacher. Admittedly, his near-perfect 2002 was an impossible act to follow, and his Bridgestone tyres put him at a disadvantage in mid-season, but there is also no doubt that Schumi made life chasing his 6th title a lot tougher for himself. For starters, with only five poles, but only one in the last ten races, he seemed rather subdued at times in the one-lap shoot-outs, although being a track cleaner on Fridays didn't help.

Mistakes in the first three races set the tone for his year, and later there was that five-race run from Europe to Hungary where he did not lead a lap and seemed resigned to scoring minor points. And of course there was Japan, where he almost made a meal of securing his record-breaking title. Still, there were enough moments of typical Michael magic, namely his hat-trick from San Marino to Austria, all of them unbelievably great drives under pressure, his victory in Canada against the odds, and his wins in Italy and the USA which stabilised his title push. Six wins meant his 6th title was definitely deserved.

Back to the top.
Points:  93 Prospects for 2004:

Momentum in F1 is a cyclic thing, and with McLaren and Williams looking strong for 2004 and Ferrari having nowhere to go but downhill, next season will be a test of Michael's motivation, especially now that he has that coveted 6th title. Will obviously still be a contender, but we wouldn't be surprised if he is finally dethroned.

WDC:  1st

Our Rating:  8.0
5. Mark Webber
Last year the Australian demonstrated that he had what it took to be a good Grand Prix driver, although he still had his rough edges. This year he showed that he is capable of greatness. Making use of the simple but effective Jaguar, no-one was more stunning in Friday qualifying as he regularly mixed it well inside the top 8. And though he tended to drop back on second qualifying, his average grid position was still just below 9th, and occasionally there were Saturday heroics too, namely starting 3rd in Brazil and 5th in San Marino, while his lap in Hungary netting him 3rd was arguably the lap of the year.

His solid race speed was no better verified than by his run of seven points-scores from ten races in mid-season, as he above anyone else made use of the new points system. Austria was particularly amazing, where he started from the pit lane, had a stop-go, and still came 7th having lapped slower only than the Ferraris. Could with luck have scored up to 30 points, and we will maintain to the grave that he could have won in Melbourne. Admittedly, there were still a few races (e.g. Britain, Japan) where he was a bit impotent with the wrong set-up, and still prone to the odd error, like in Brazil and the USA.

Back to the top.
Points:  17 Prospects for 2004:

There is every chance that Webber may be going to Williams in 2005, so to solidify his position he must continue his 2003 form next season. With Jaguar on the up, and with unheralded rookie driver in Christian Klien alongside him, he will have every opportunity to continue to impress.

WDC:  10th

Our Rating:  8.0
6. Jenson Button
There were few more impressive drivers on Sundays this year than Jenson Button. Settling in very well at BAR, he managed to mould an excellent spirit around him, capitalising on team-mate Villeneuve's increasing estrangement from the team. If he ever cast a jealous eye over the success his former employers Renault were having, then he didn't show it. Nor did he let Villeneuve's mind games in the early part of the season get to him. Instead he knuckled down to his task, and with 17 points beat Mark Webber on count-back as the 'best of the rest' driver after those from the big four teams.

Qualifying remained one of the his weaknesses, and though he had seven top-ten starts including 5th in Spain, there was also a mid-season stretch from Canada to Hungary where he started no higher than 12th. Perhaps this was the after-effect of his huge Monaco crash. But it's on race day that you bring home the bacon, and this year Button was consistently excellent. Notable drives included finishing 9th from the back of the grid in Britain, and 8th from 17th in Germany, while deserved 4ths in Austria and Japan were the major highlights, and he was desperately unlucky to miss a podium at Indy.

Back to the top.
Points:  17 Prospects for 2004:

Much has been made of the fact that next year Button becomes a team leader for the first time. But regardless of how Sato does, Jenson has a chance to assert himself, and with Michelin tyres, a stronger Honda engine, and better qualifying pace to match his race pace, he could well give the big four teams some headaches.

WDC:  9th

Our Rating:  7.5
7. Rubens Barrichello
In the face of the brilliant championship battle, and some of Michael's well-documented mid-season troubles, Ferrari's other driver ended up being lost amongst the headlines for much of the season. It was another typical Rubens year - at times faceless, usually solid, occasionally brilliant, with two wins, three poles and three fastest laps. The brilliant bits were, of course, his two wins at Silverstone and Suzuka. The way he aggressively passed his rivals in Britain made it the best drive this year by anyone, while his triumph in Japan came under enormous pressure considering the championship position.

Barrichello's hoodoo on home soil in Brazil continued, just as he looked odds-on to claim an emotional victory there. He also continued to show that he can match it with Michael, losing 6-10 in their grid battle but having a better average grid position than Schumi, even if you disregard Michael's rain-affected Suzuka effort. However, he also made some crucial errors, such as jump-starting in Australia, spinning on lap one in France and losing his front wings in Canada. Plus, whilst his consistent points-scoring could not be faulted, too often that extra special bit of magic we were hoping for simply never came.

Back to the top.
Points:  65 Prospects for 2004:

Rubinho's future with Ferrari is unclear after 2004, so next season will be an important year for him. There is no better team player in F1, but perhaps it's time for him to make a mark for himself. He does have the speed to compete with Michael, he just needs to use it. More Silverstone-like drives required from the Brazilian.

WDC:  4th

Our Rating:  7.0
8. Ralf Schumacher
The younger Schuey continued to utterly perplex in 2003. There were those early-season events when he couldn't cope with one-lap qualifying, like starting 17th at Sepang. There was that run when he finished the first seven races in the points without recording a single podium. There was Imola, where along with Michael he was in grief over his mother's passing and cathartically fought his brother for the lead in the early stages, only to watch the Ferrari win and himself slide down to 4th. There was Canada, where he sat on Michael's tail in the closing stages without ever looking like making a move.

Then there was that mid-season streak of three poles in four races, and two dominant wins at the Nurburgring and Magny-Cours. There was that sensational drive in Hungary, when he scythed through the field and made mincemeat of his brother. But there were also those daft moments when he stayed on dries at Indy and crashed, and when he pointlessly battled Michael at Suzuka. At times Ralf is too staid and not racy enough. At other times he will be brilliantly forceful but also so ridiculously foolish you wished he was back to his conservative self. All in all, still not the total package he needs to be.

Back to the top.
Points:  58 Prospects for 2004:

With Montoya due to go to McLaren, Ralf is now looking like being Williams' main man for the next few seasons. But he desperately needs to find the right balance of aggression, speed, consistency and mental strength if he is going to challenge for the championship and not get swamped by the hungry next generation.

WDC:  5th

Our Rating:  7.0
9. Cristiano da Matta
Da Matta came into F1 this year with a CART title in his pocket, but no-one actually thought of him as having the raw talent to rock the establishment. Even now there's no suggestion that he will be one of the major players of the next generation, but he undoubtedly impressed throughout 2003 with his consistency, and deserved his unofficial rookie of the year status. Bear in mind also that he had to learn many of the circuits for the first time, and that as the only rookie not to participate in Friday testing he often only had one hours' free practice before competing in Friday qualifying.

True, he was severely out-qualified by Panis 3 to 13, but he outscored his team-mate 10 points to 6. Admittedly he did have significantly better reliability, and at times he did have a safer strategy. But he often made better use of his tactics than Panis, and even though he didn't set the world on fire in every race, his dependability was what impressed, with only one race-ending error, and that in his first race in Melbourne. His spirited battle with Ralf Schumacher in Spain for 5th, and the convincing manner in which he led at Silverstone, were highlights in what was an extremely solid debut season.

Back to the top.
Points:  10 Prospects for 2004:

There is no reason why Cristiano can't impress further in 2004. But along with his team he will need to up his game. Showing that he can be competitive and keep his car on the track is one thing, but showing that he can put up a fight when the opportunity arises is another matter altogether. Ought to increase his points haul.

WDC:  13th

Our Rating:  7.0
10. Jarno Trulli
We learnt nothing new about Trulli in 2003 - or did we? Paired with the driver of the year, scoring 33 points to Alonso's 55, and taking only one podium to the Spaniard's four, it may have seemed like another fairly mediocre season for the originally overrated Italian. But while their qualifying duel was split 8 apiece, Alonso only started in the top six on six occasions, whereas Trulli managed it eleven times. That, plus some of his spectacular low-fuel Friday qualifying runs, like in Hungary and Japan, confirmed him as one of the best qualifiers in the business. But we knew that already.

We also knew that there will be those frustrating moments where Jarno needs to stand up and be counted but fails to do so. A woeful weekend at Imola, dropping to 6th on the grid in Hungary, and finishing 6th at Silverstone having led early were all examples of that. Indeed, he only finished ahead of his start position 5 times out of 11. But, as we started to see in 2002, Trulli was developing as a racer, and some excellent late-season drives proved that. He had the speed all weekend to actually win in Japan were it not for the Saturday rain, and that said much for Trulli's development as a rounded F1 driver.

Back to the top.
Points:  33 Prospects for 2004:

Trulli is no longer the next big thing in F1 - his team-mate is, and it seems Jarno's comfortable with that. That's actually going to help his driving in 2004. Much will of course depend on how competitive the Renault is next year, but if it's still 'big four' material, there will be many more points and perhaps regular podiums for Jarno.

WDC:  8th

Our Rating:  6.5
11. David Coulthard
With only 51 points, equivalent to just 33 under last year's system, only a single win and no poles or fastest laps, 2003 was DC's worst season in F1 since his first with McLaren back in 1996. He failed to reach to finish six times, but scored points in the other ten races. Yet his tally consisted of only three podiums, a 4th, no less than five 5ths, and a 7th. What those figures don't reflect is how stunningly he had often raced to get up to those positions. Only twice did he finish below his grid position. But, in a championship-challenging car, it was a lot less than Ron Dennis would have expected.

The Scot's downfall was an appalling inability to come to grips with single-lap qualifying. Though the final qualifying score was 10-6 to Raikkonen, three of the six were Kimi errors and one was the rain at Suzuka. The new rules for 2003 were to do with putting pressure on the drivers, and in the shootouts Coulthard simply came up short. He realised the problem and knew his personal demons every time he went out, but overcoming them was beyond him. By season's end, it was arguable that he now had too much baggage from too many failed titled bids to withstand the new generation coming through.

Back to the top.
Points:  51 Prospects for 2004:

Upon the announcement that Montoya is joining McLaren in 2005, most have taken it for granted that it's DC who will be replaced. If the MP4/19 is as good as intended, then Coulthard will need to stop all that self-examination and, as Nike might say, 'just do it'. Could well be his final season in F1 though.

WDC:  7th

Our Rating:  6.0
12. Olivier Panis
When Panis joined Toyota with all the reputation in the world for being a great car developer, everyone thought that this would be Olivier's swansong to a career that has deserved more. Unfortunately the first season of his two-year deal has not turned out that way, team-mate da Matta out-scoring the Frenchman 10 to 6. But that is not to deny his Saturday achievements. For someone regarded as a poor one-lap man, Olivier shone by qualifying in the top ten 12 times, including a 3rd, a 4th, a 5th, a 6th and two 7ths, and an average grid spot of 9th made him the 'best of the rest' in that regard.

Mind you, that was often because of Toyota's low-fuel strategies, which saw Panis drop down the field all too often. One wonders if, with all his experience, he could have had more say in his tactics. And, as a renowned racer, one questions why he sometimes seemed to meekly accept the fact that he was going to fall down the order instead of putting up more of a fight. Terrible reliability didn't help, with nine retirements (seven mechanical) to da Matta's four. In the end, maybe his uncharacteristic alleged drunken rampage with the Schumachers after Suzuka showed just how frustrating this season had been!

Back to the top.
Points:  6 Prospects for 2004:

It is expected that 2004 will be Panis' final year in F1. He and his team must realise that the race is won on Sunday, not Saturday. With a better and more reliable car, and more orthodox tactics, Olivier still has what it takes to bring home a bevy of points, and may well score Toyota's first ever podium.

WDC:  15th

Our Rating:  6.0
Some images used here are Copyright © Formula1.com and © F1Racing.net.
For enlarged versions, please visit their sites!


F1 Rejects
Back to 2003 Season Review
Main Page   |    Drivers Index   |   Reject Teams   |   Hall of Shame
Featured Rejects
Reject Statistics
Submit-a-Reject
FAQ / Copyright
Reject CENTRALE
• Latest GP Review
• Other Articles
• Links / Banner
Sign Guestbook
Read Guestbook
Current Poll
Previous Polls
All original content Copyright © 1999-2003 Formula One Rejects.