2004 Drivers 13-25 Review

SchuJPMButtonJacques

An in-depth look at the past season, team by team and driver by driver

Back to
2004 Season Review
Back to
Reject CENTRALE
Go to
Text-Only Version
13. Ralf Schumacher
14. Nick Heidfeld
15. Christian Klien
16. Zsolt Baumgartner
17. Olivier Panis
18. Cristiano da Matta
19. Gianmaria Bruni
20. Giorgio Pantano
N/A: Marc Gené
N/A: Timo Glock
N/A: Antonio Pizzonia
N/A: Jacques Villeneuve
N/A: Ricardo Zonta

13. Ralf Schumacher
At the start of the year, Autosport assistant editor David Malsher predicted that Ralf Schumacher would win the world championship. If the Williams was good enough, then assuming that Ralf would be his usual consistent self, and if the German also pulled out a few more of those special drives we know he's capable of, then a title win was not beyond the bounds of possibility. If nothing else, his contract negotiations with Williams should have been incentive for him to perform, right? But not only was the car nowhere near good enough, but Ralf also fell into more of a slumber than usual.

Instead of those negotiations spurring him to greater heights, he and Willi Weber overplayed their hand and asked for too much money, then backed it up with rubbish like Ralf's brainless drive in Bahrain. As discussions broke down, he descended into a spiralling sequence of unmotivated drives and collisions, culminating in his horrific shunt at Indianapolis. On the positive side, after signing for Toyota for 2005 his return races had a little bit more life, and he could point to two sterling races in Canada and Japan, as we've come to expect. But it was nowhere near enough for a driver of his ability.

Back to the top.
Points:  24 Prospects for 2005:

The last time he switched teams, he was almost driver of the year for Williams in 1999. Perhaps the challenge of taking Toyota to the top, with a competitive team-mate in Jarno Trulli, will push him to perform more at his best, more of the time. It's the least that Toyota's paying him the megabucks for.

WDC:  9th

Our Rating:  6.0
14. Nick Heidfeld
It's hard to know exactly what to make of the quiet German's season. The statistics show that on average he was a tiny bit better than 16th in Saturday qualifying, which either means that he was consistently beating one midfield rival, or, as is more likely, there was always at least one car that didn't record a time on Saturday. A shocking run with reliability in the first half of the season was tempered by two points-scoring results in Monaco and Canada, but while the finishing record improved in the last nine races, not once did he finish in the top ten.

Here's what the statistics don't say. In the pre-season, it was largely Heidfeld's technical feedback that made the recalcitrant Jordan as good as it could possibly have been. Nick unstintingly extracted as much as he could from the car all season - albeit no more than that, I'm afraid. Generally he lapped consistently, and when he was mixing it in the midfield, like at the Nurburgring, he looked at ease. He also didn't publicly express his hurt when Eddie Jordan stopped him from going to Williams to stand in for Ralf Schumacher. Perhaps he understood that that was really backhanded praise from EJ.

Back to the top.
Points:  3 Prospects for 2005:

Memo to Williams: please give Heidfeld the seat alongside Mark Webber. He's not inconsistent like Pizzonia, inexperienced like Davidson, nor old like Coulthard. He can do a perfectly consistent points-gathering job, and his speed is not shabby at all. It would be scandalous to see him miss out on a top drive yet again.

WDC:  18th

Our Rating:  6.0
15. Christian Klien
By default the 2004 rookie of the year, the baby-faced, earring-wearing Austrian showed he was not out of his depth in F1, but also showed that there wasn't enough promise for Jaguar to have taken him other than for his Red Bull money. Though he was on the wrong end of a 15 to 3 qualifying battle with team-mate Webber, he started all bar two races between 10th and 15th. Suffering only one mechanical retirement in Barcelona, when he settled into a race rhythm he consistently brought the Jaguar home, not necessarily at earth-shattering pace, but culminating in a fortunate 6th in Belgium.

Trouble was, in those moments when he didn't settle down he was liable to get caught up in incidents. He collided with Heidfeld in Monaco, got caught up in first corner fracas in both North American races, got hit by Coulthard and Michael Schumacher at Spa and Shanghai, and took off his team-mate in Jaguar's farewell race in Brazil. His early dice with Raikkonen in Bahrain was one of the more memorable moments of the season, but also typified how Klien tended to get over-aggressive in both attack and defence whilst battling with another driver. By year's end, there was still much improving to do.

Back to the top.
Points:  3 Prospects for 2005:

As one of Red Bull's ordained drivers, with the energy drink company having bought out the remnants of Jaguar, Klien has a decent chance of staying in F1. Otherwise he is likely to get overlooked. Having said that, Red Bull might still prefer the likes of Liuzzi and Allmendinger. Christian may yet be left out in the cold.

WDC:  17th

Our Rating:  5.5
16. Zsolt Baumgartner
It may come as a surprise that the Hungarian did not make it onto our 'Reject of the Year' podium. No, Baumgartner was not good enough to deserve his place in the top flight, but frankly he won the paddock's respect - as well as ours - as someone who was aware of his abilities, who had a diligent and strong work ethic, and who pleasantly surprised with his improvement as the season wore on, to the point where he was within 3 seconds of pole in Brazil. As we keep saying, but it is worth repeating here, that time would have been good enough for pole at Interlagos last year.

In addition, he provided one of the feel-good moments of 2004 when he scored a point in 8th place for his beleaguered team at Indianapolis, albeit by default. Even if he spun out of races three times, usually he was able to keep his car safely and consistently on the road, and his finishing record was generally good. Polite whilst being lapped, at the end of the day, even if he remained a pay driver in every sense of the term, he exceeded everyone's expectations, set and achieved realistic targets, and deserved to finish the season free of the derision his participation received at the start of the year.

Back to the top.
Points:  1 Prospects for 2005:

Baumgartner wants to continue in F1 in 2005 in some capacity, even as a tester, but even he concedes it will be hard to find the kind of backing that secured his drive this year. Still, the experience he's gained this year will hold him in good stead, should he decide to step down into one of the new junior categories.

WDC:  20th

Our Rating:  5.0
17. Olivier Panis
There are few friendlier people in the pit lane than the veteran Frenchman, but sadly, 2004 was a season too many for Olivier. Yes Toyota needed a good car developer, but perhaps what they needed more was someone who could provide a spark on Sunday afternoons. And despite his reputation for being a strong racer, Panis' race efforts this year were all too placid. Though he still had a good turn of speed, qualifying in the top ten on no fewer than eight occasions, only three points finishes and six points, four of them in the attrition-hit USA GP, was a poor conversion rate.

Either his grid positions were wasted by problems getting off the line, or disappointing mid-race speed and/or poor strategy would see him fall down the field on race day. Races like those at the Nurburgring, in Shanghai and at Suzuka, where his opening stint boded well only for him to fade into anonymity, typified his season. After establishing his reputation up to 1997, and enhancing it as McLaren tester in 2000, it was somewhat painful to watch his steadily decline in the last four seasons as a force to be reckoned with. The 2004 season was not the kind of legacy Panis deserved to leave.

Back to the top.
Points:  6 Prospects for 2005:

Olivier will continue with Toyota in 2005, out of the limelight and doing what he's probably best at these days, testing and developing rather than racing. Instead of being required to inspire the team forward, there's Gascoyne, Trulli and Ralf Schumacher to do that. In a support role, he will be more in his element.

WDC:  14th

Our Rating:  5.0
18. Cristiano da Matta
At first glance down the 2004 results sheet, Cristiano's record in his twelve races this season before Toyota gave him the boot doesn't look that bad. His average grid position was around 11th or 12th, roughly where his car ought to have been. His finishing record was creditable, and he added another three points with 6th place at Monaco. But this was a former Champ Car series winner. This was last year's rookie of the year, a man who qualified 3rd at Suzuka, led comfortably at Silverstone, and battled a Williams at Barcelona. Frankly, we expected more improvement from the Brazilian.

It was an evenly average year in terms of driving quality, with all our drivers ranked from 18th to 4th scoring between 5 and 7 out of 10. Added to that the high reliability rate, and drivers needed to produce the occasional special something to catch the attention. Da Matta failed to register a blip on the radar all year. Perhaps disillusioned by the inadequacies of his car, but more likely wallowing in self-doubt as he continued to over-analyse his inability to get used to F1 cornering technique, with Toyota lining up their drivers for 2005 it was probably a relief for all concerned that his tenure ended early.

Back to the top.
Points:  3 Prospects for 2005:

Reports suggest that Cristiano is trying to get a budget together to return to Champ cars with Newman Haas next year. It would be good to see him go back there. It would bolster that series' credibility, and da Matta is more likely to flourish in an environment where he feels comfortable. In F1 he was a fish out of water.

WDC:  16th

Our Rating:  5.0
19. Gianmaria Bruni
Another Italian rookie, another disappointment. Bruni arrived from European F3000 after some impressive runs as Minardi's Friday tester in 2003, with hopes that he would prove to be a talent, and not just a pay driver. Unfortunately, Gimmi was unable or unwilling to extend himself beyond the quality of his car, which was rather miserable to begin with. Admittedly, he suffered all manner of reliability issues and incidents, from brake and gearbox failures to losing a front wheel in China, from being hit by his team-mate at Spa to his pit fire at Monza, all of which probably dented his confidence.

What appeared to be most frustrating, though, was his attitude. Expected to ritually hammer his lowly-rated team-mate in Zsolt Baumgartner, even if he was generally faster than the Hungarian, he was content to saunter through a race weekend, and from race to race, which was in contrast to Baumgartner's diligent and hard-working approach. That wasn't just our impression; Wilux boss Ruud Wildschut was scathing in his condemnation, and even Paul Stoddart hinted that he could pull his finger out a little more. Minardi didn't need to be just carrying someone along for the ride.

Back to the top.
Points:  0 Prospects for 2005:

To be fair, Bruni's reputation hasn't been shot down in flames like, say, Pantano's, so it wouldn't be a surprise to see him get a second chance with Minardi. But, obviously, so much depends on money. Alternatively, there's a range of other open-wheeler categories he could handily slot into, and he'd make a good sportscar driver too.

WDC:  25th

Our Rating:  4.5
20. Giorgio Pantano
For a man who had been a winner in F3000, and who had been dubbed a mercurial talent, the Italian's 14 races for Jordan were frustrating for observers hoping for a flash of inspiration from him. One can only guess what effect it had on Eddie Jordan, who no doubt chose him for his money - which he was slow on delivering anyway - and for his reputed speed, which simply didn't materialise. Fed up with his under-performing racer, EJ replaced him with Glock in Canada, who promptly scored two points on debut, and then kicked him out for good with three races in the season left.

Though he was unlucky in terms of the EJ14's reliability, Pantano could do no better than 15th quickest in Saturday qualifying, and finished no higher than 13th. Either he was too conservative, or when he pushed harder more often than not he went over the limit. His spin into retirement at Silverstone, after he mindlessly put half his car out onto the grass, was the height of silliness, and he crashed into Bruni at Spa even though he may well have avoided the Minardi. Driving for Jordan this year was not an easy task, but his first season in F1 was a test which he failed dismally. An undisputed 'Reject of the Year'.

Back to the top.
Points:  0 Prospects for 2005:

Unfortunately Pantano now has form, for on-track performances and for bringing sponsorship money. That form isn't good. Not to worry; there's no shortage of junior open-wheeler categories for him to choose from next year. As long as he can find another portfolio of sponsors, GP2 or Formula Superfund beckons.

WDC:  24th

Our Rating:  3.5
Marc Gené
Unlike the Italian GP last year, when the Spaniard filled in for Ralf Schumacher and impressively came home 5th, given a similar opportunity at Magny-Cours and Silverstone this year, he only finished 10th and 12th respectively. Williams then looked to Pizzonia instead. In fairness to the loyal tester, those two races coincided with the time when Williams was at its lowest trough this year before they started turning the corner. They didn't represent what he was capable of. Rumours have him becoming a tester for Ferrari in 2005; at any rate, there's no F1 race seat in the offing.

Back to the top.
Timo Glock
The German's time with Jordan started inauspiciously, crashing at a Barcelona test. But piloting their third car on Fridays, he learnt the car and built up speed. He was rewarded when he was called in at short notice to deputise for Pantano in Canada, and after a mistake-free drive came home 11th on the road, which became 7th and two points after the disqualifications. Three more steady drives at year's end, each netting a 15th place, but 6th fastest on Friday in the wet at Suzuka, suggested that he ought to have raced the Jordan all along. Deserves another chance with them in 2005.

Back to the top.
Antonio Pizzonia
Question marks remain over 'Jungle Boy'. Given four races with Williams, it was unclear whether he would still bear the scars of his thrashing by Mark Webber at Jaguar in 2003. Though he came 7th in Germany, he was beaten there by the Aussie too, and his comments about his treatment by Jaguar were distasteful. Another 7th in Hungary was followed by an excellent drive at Spa, where he could have come 3rd, but he followed it up by over-driving at Monza. Supposedly on top of the list to partner Webber again in 2004, but on strength of evidence it would be a very risky choice.

Back to the top.
Jacques Villeneuve
Whether or not you're a fan of the Canadian, it was good to have the ex-champion back. But sadly, a lapped 10th, 11th and 11th in his three races suggested that it was taking him too long to get back up to speed. He admitted a lack of race fitness himself. But to be fair, this was a difficult, understeering Renault that didn't suit his style, plus the car was starting to go backwards by the time he sat it in, and it was the notorious - inferior? - second car as well. Has he still got it? Who knows? But at Sauber next year he will have a less-pressurised environment to answer that question.

Back to the top.
Ricardo Zonta
Given five races at the end of the season as part of Toyota's merry-go-round of drivers, the Brazilian showed that he was little more than the journeyman he had become since his early days with BAR. The lack of regular racing had taken the edge off him, and all along he knew he was just keeping the seat warm for someone else. Suffered Toyota's only race engine failure with three laps to go at Spa, heart-breakingly when lying in a brilliant 4th, but in a race of attrition he was probably lucky to be there at all. Admittedly, by year's end the TF104B was going nowhere. Returns to testing duties in 2005.

Back to the top.
Some images used here are Copyright © Formula1.com and © F1Racing.net.
For enlarged versions, please visit their sites!


F1 Rejects
Back to 2004 Season Review
Main Page   |    Drivers Index   |   Reject Teams   |   Hall of Shame
Reject Extras
Reject Interviews
Submit-a-Reject
FAQ / Copyright
Reject CENTRALE
• Latest GP Review
• Other Articles
• Links / Banner
Sign Guestbook
Read Guestbook
Current Poll
Previous Polls
All original content Copyright © 1999-2004 Formula One Rejects.