|
2004 Top 12 Drivers Review
An in-depth look at the past season, team by team and driver by driver |
||||
| Back to 2004 Season Review | Back to Reject CENTRALE | Go to Text-Only Version | ||
|
||||
| 1. Michael Schumacher | ||||||
|
If you're only as good as your last race, then people's opinions of Michael Schumacher's season will be tainted by his royal stuff-ups in China and Brazil, where his intensity level dropped several degrees. But if you take his focus in the other 16 races into account and average it out, no driver came remotely close in terms of concentration and motivation. Matched with a personalised car, raw speed and sheer relentlessness, the result was that no driver came close on the scoresheet either. 13 wins, eight poles, ten fastest laps, 148 points, and a 7th world title made it as conclusively dominant a year as 2002 had been.
Let's not delude ourselves into thinking that the car did all the work - and even if it did, it was the result of the German uniting the rest of the team, and his diligence in always perfecting his set-up. Otherwise, he blew Barrichello away, he was awesome when fighting others on the same strategy, as in Canada, and he dared to try different tactics and made them work too. His masterclass at Magny-Cours will live long in the memory. Yes, Monaco, China and Brazil and others proved he was human after all, but at Suzuka, where sheer skill, adaptability and brilliance won the day, he was untouchable. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 2. Jenson Button | ||||||
|
However promising winter testing may have been, Jenson could probably hardly imagine that he would spend the season as a regular fixture on the podium. He also would not have known what kind of pressure was involved in being a de facto 'team leader', responsible for carrying his team. But, with a responsive BAR under him and a cocktail of speed, smoothness, savvy and consistency, the Englishman adapted to life as a frontrunner and as a number one driver as if he'd always been there. A comfortable 3rd in the title, 85 points, ten podiums and one pole said it all.
Such was his appetite for points, were it not for his three retirements he would have scored in every race. His drive at Hockenheim was memorable, where but for an engine change and a loose helmet he could have challenged for that elusive maiden victory. And therein lay the main criticism of Jenson, if there was any: his win and fastest lap columns remained at zero. Only rarely in races did he seem to be pushing right to the very edge; you always felt he had a tiny bit more left. Or was that simply a function of his ultra-smooth style? Alain Prost never needed tail-slides to go extremely fast... Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 3. Kimi Raikkonen | ||||||
|
Given his ice-cool demeanour, it's easy to forget how young and relatively inexperienced the Finn is; 2004 only marked his 6th year of car racing. As a result, after his championship near-thing in 2003, the awfulness of the McLaren MP4/19 probably hurt Kimi more than he let out, although there were occasional signs of frustration, such as in Malaysia. His early-season performances, punctuated by endless engine failures that made his qualifying and race stats look abysmal, were also affected as he grappled with mediocrity. Coulthard was certainly matching him early on.
It's easy to suggest that it was the MP4/19B that revived his form, but that's not entirely true. By the North American races he had regrouped and was starting to leave DC well behind. And just how good was the back-end of his season? Although he came 2nd in Britain and Brazil, and 3rd in China, he was in contention to win all three, and he had a chance of walking away with Germany and Italy too. And he did win at Spa - beating Michael on the king's favourite playground. With luck, that's five or more wins he could have had. However you look at it, that was pretty awesome. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 4. Rubens Barrichello | ||||||
|
It's never easy to evaluate Rubens' season. OK, he scored 114 points, but the truth is that for three-quarters of the season, he was practically obliterated by his team-mate. But when that person is Michael Schumacher, it's almost excusable. The Brazilian also picked up two fine, truly-deserved victories at Monza and Shanghai, but in Italy he was at less of a disadvantage than Michael, and in China the German was taking a holiday. Whereas sometimes there are drivers who seem to be able to do no wrong, it often appears as though Rubens can do no right.
The rest of his season saw 13 podiums, including seven 2nd places. Given that he was driving a Ferrari F2004, that was not entirely unexpected, but to give credit where credit's due, it was solid, mistake-free, consistent work. However, there was little of the Schumacher-beating speed that we've occasionally seen in previous years, and that was disappointing. Another down-side was his all-too-regular litany of pathetic excuses, blaming all manner of car problems for his inability to beat Michael. He'd have been better off simply admitting that Schumi was in completely peerless form. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 5. Giancarlo Fisichella | ||||||
|
2004 was meant to be the year in which, by joining Sauber, Fisi gained a foothold in the Ferrari camp. Initially, things didn't look good though. Out-performed by team-mate Felipe Massa in the first three races, he then finished 9th at Imola having started 18th after not recording a time on Saturday. That seemed to rekindle his confidence in races. From Imola to the end of the season, a 12th and two retirements aside, including his spectacular flip at Monaco, he never finished out of the top nine and scored 22 points in the process, almost breaking into the top 10 of the drivers' championship.
The Italian was the master of maximising heavy-fuel strategies for mid-race position gain. Despite some mediocre qualifying efforts, brilliant drives came thick and fast, like at the Nurburgring where he again started 18th but finished 6th, or in Canada (11th to 4th), Britain (last to 6th) and Italy (15th to 8th). Spa was also a highlight, where he started and finished 5th, and was constantly competitive. By mid-season, he didn't need Ferrari any more; Williams and Renault were both knocking on his door. Suddenly, top teams were wanting him and courting him all over again. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 6. Takuma Sato | ||||||
|
For the first half of the season at least, Taku-san was F1's Mr Excitement. He had speed to burn, occasionally matching and beating Jenson Button, even if the consistency was not there. 5th on the grid in Bahrain gave him the confidence over one lap, and it became 3rd in Spain and the front row at the Nurburgring. But whether it was as a result of his hard driving, or just an inherent defect in his Honda engines, the first ten races saw no less than six engine detonations during races, the notable at Monaco and his heart-breaker in the European GP. Plus we could be assured of the odd spin here and there.
But Indianapolis was a turning point. He qualified third, raced like a man possessed, pulled off several high-quality passing moves, and scored his maiden podium. From there the Japanese driver's race results became more consistent, with a brace of 6ths and 4ths. But strangely his pace fell slightly off his team-mate's, although his engines were staying intact. Were the two connected? At any rate, 8th in the championship and 34 points showed that he was worthy F1 material. However, did we prefer the hard-charging Taku or the consistent one who picked up points? Not sure. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 7. Jarno Trulli | ||||||
|
This was a season in two parts for the pineapple-haired Italian. Up to the French GP, he was one of the drivers of the year. Finally combining solid race pace with blistering qualifying speed, he was scoring points with ease as team-mate Alonso faltered. He beat Fernando to the podium on the latter's home soil in Spain, and backed it up with one of the drives of the year to take an assured maiden win in Monaco. Add to that four 4ths, two 5ths and a 7th, and Jarno looked like finishing at least 4th in the championship, leaving his much-vaunted stablemate in his wake. But then came Magny-Cours.
There, he asked to leave Flavio Briatore's management at the same time as renegotiating his Renault contract - a horrible political move. He then lost a podium place on the last corner, and out of nowhere the battle lines between him and Briatore were drawn. His claims of inferior treatment thereafter were probably true, but his performances suggested that he himself had gone into an inexcusable stupor. His switch to Toyota brought him back to life a little, and even then, he maintained his perfect top ten qualifying record, apart from Indy where he started from the back of the grid. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 8. Mark Webber | ||||||
|
This was an awfully frustrating season for Mark. All season, he drove at 110% and maximised his Jaguar's potential. There was no better evidence of that than in qualifying, where he started 14th three times, but otherwise always started 12th or higher. The sixth or seventh row was roughly where the R5 belonged, so it meant that the Australian was always reaching the limit of his car's ability, or exceeding it by his own immense speed and skill. His hot laps in Australia and Malaysia, and to a lesser extent his lap in Japan, were amongst the best on-the-edge, banzai laps all season.
But in a year when points were hard to come by, whenever he was in a good position to score, events conspired against him. He had mechanical problems in Melbourne and Monaco, and at Imola and Indy, all when points were within reach, and his seat heated up mysteriously at Suzuka. When his car was reliable, so were others. Then Webber himself made uncharacteristic mistakes in races, like his debacles at Sepang and Spa, both of which earned him 'Reject of the Race'. The way he remained loyal to Jaguar to the very end was admirable though, despite greener pastures at Williams coming up. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 9. Fernando Alonso | ||||||
|
By usual standards, it was not a bad year for the Spaniard, who equalled his tally of four podiums from 2003, moved his championship position up from 6th to 4th, and bettered his total points haul from last year. It was just that we expected so much more. Last season, in an eminently driveable and well-handling car, he astonished everyone with his mid-race speed that regularly vaulted him up the order. This year that pace seemed to disappear with the understeering characteristics of the R24, and Alonso was left as merely a consistent points-scorer with twelve points finishes, all between 2nd and 7th.
In truth, while Trulli's heart was still in it and Renault gave him the machinery to match, Alonso was being shaded by his team-mate in both qualifying and race. Fernando's one-lap performances this year were up-and-down, and with three races to go he was still yet to pass Trulli's points tally, although the Italian had not scored for five events. Alonso's year was also marked by some displays of impetuosity and carelessness, like when he threw it away at Monza, and some of which verged on arrogance, like his ill-directed anger towards Webber in Bahrain and towards Ralf Schumacher at Monaco. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 10. David Coulthard | ||||||
|
On paper, this was perhaps the Scot's least convincing season thus far. It was the first time he had failed to get onto the podium during the season, and he wound up only 10th in the championship with a meagre 24 points. There were only glimpses of his inherent speed, and although he became more accustomed to one-lap qualifying, he still wasn't brilliant at it. In the latter half of the season, whilst in Raikkonen's hands the MP4/19B became a potential race-winner, DC managed no better than 4th at Hockenheim, and on several occasions he couldn't make a heavy-fuel strategy work, like in Italy and China.
But by far Coulthard's most valuable attribute in 2004 was his consistency. Nurburgring aside, he started all but four races between 8th and 12th, and the other four he started in the top six. With better reliability than Kimi, he finished twelve times in the top ten, including a run from Canada to China in which he finished every race between 4th and 9th. Whilst usually speed is valued more highly than consistency, especially at the start of the season when the team got desperate and Raikkonen got flustered, DC was ultra-professional, the rock that stabilised the team. He was what his team needed him to be. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 11. Juan Pablo Montoya | ||||||
|
Having decided last year on a huff that he would drive for McLaren in 2005, there is no reason to doubt that the Colombian was desperate to leave Williams with the world title in 2004. But it soon became abundantly clear that the quality of the FW26 would thwart his chances. Podiums in Malaysia and San Marino, and almost one in Bahrain as well were it not for a last-gasp gearbox problem, had him in the fight for 3rd overall, but then a DNF in Spain, collisions with the Schumachers at Monaco and the Nurburgring, and the double-disqualification in Canada and the USA stopped his points-scoring momentum.
At that point, Williams was at its lowest ebb. Although the team regrouped towards the end of the year, by this point JPM had well and truly nothing to play for. His second half of the season saw one retirement and eight points finishes, but they included an 8th, a 7th, four 5ths and a 4th. Although still able to pull out a banzai lap, in races he was giving 95% at best. But when he did have something to aim for in Brazil, to give Williams a farewell present, we all know what happened. Overall, a consistent scoring year, by no means a hard-trying one, but we could sympathise with his plight. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
| 12. Felipe Massa | ||||||
|
The Brazilian ranks as highly as he does on the strength of the back end of his season, when finally he began delivering on all that promise he's supposed to have. After a year as a Ferrari tester, he came back to F1 slightly less wild, more able to keep his Sauber on the road, but at the cost of his speed. Though he recorded five top ten finishes in the first half of the season, not once did he qualify in the top ten and on five occasions in succession he started 15th or lower. We described him as descending into anonymity, which was perhaps worse than being known as fast but erratic.
Massa turned the corner at Silverstone though, in a solid race that saw him start 10th and finish 9th. Though his qualifying performances for the rest of the season fluctuated, including two 4ths in China and Brazil when he did his hot lap on relatively low fuel, his race performances suggested that his inherent speed was back, as he started to match team-mate Fisichella. He proved to be an adept passer, making several daring and memorable moves, especially on Raikkonen in Melbourne, although he was relatively easy to pass himself. But clearly, this rough diamond was being refined. Back to the top. |
||||||
|
||||||
|
Some images used here are Copyright © Formula1.com and © F1Racing.net. For enlarged versions, please visit their sites! |
||||||
| |||
| Back to 2004 Season Review | |||
| Main Page | Drivers Index | Reject Teams | Hall of Shame | |||
|
Reject Extras Reject Interviews Submit-a-Reject FAQ / Copyright |
Reject CENTRALE Latest GP Review Other Articles Links / Banner |
Sign Guestbook Read Guestbook Current Poll Previous Polls |
|
|
|
|||
| All original content Copyright © 1999-2004 Formula One Rejects. | |||