Things you miss about F1...

The place for anything and everything else to do with F1 history, different forms of motorsport, and all other randomness

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby dr-baker » 27 Jul 2011, 07:07

Dropped scores - is this the answer to today's super-reliability and risk-aversion? The 1950s had best 4 from 8 results, or best 5 from 9. So now, we would best 10 from 19 (pro rata). Although this might mean that Vettel would get a near-perfect score this year, it would not matter if you extract a bit more reliability from the car, because if you blow up, you simply reign it in a bit for the next race and know that it would go towards a dropped score. Equally, if you're Lewis Hamilton, you might not worry quite so much from a grid penalty, if it does not lead to one of your best 10 results of the year.

I bet someone can see a flaw in this somewhere...
As hardcore as a peach...

West Cliff Results 2015
F1RM WEC: 1st (drivers)/2nd (teams)
F3RWRS: 3rd (drivers)/3rd (teams)
Whoop whoop.
User avatar
dr-baker
 
Posts: 8271
Joined: 30 Mar 2009, 03:30
Location: at my laptop

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Klon » 28 Jul 2011, 22:16

dr-baker wrote:Dropped scores - is this the answer to today's super-reliability and risk-aversion? The 1950s had best 4 from 8 results, or best 5 from 9. So now, we would best 10 from 19 (pro rata). Although this might mean that Vettel would get a near-perfect score this year, it would not matter if you extract a bit more reliability from the car, because if you blow up, you simply reign it in a bit for the next race and know that it would go towards a dropped score. Equally, if you're Lewis Hamilton, you might not worry quite so much from a grid penalty, if it does not lead to one of your best 10 results of the year.

I bet someone can see a flaw in this somewhere...


Heeere! Teams wouldn't go with a risky approach, they would try to seal the title as soon as they could with their super reliable cars and by not throwing points away. Especially in a year like this that would merely lead to everyone doing their stuff until Hungary and then we would see an artificial entertainment program. Although that might lead to most top teams using their test drivers which would be neat as well...
Forget my objections, let's do this.
21:38 - Dark77 - *plays rfactor champcar 2007 mod*
21:38 - Dark77 - *3 copies of orial seriva start last*
21:38 - Dark77 - wat
21:38 - Salamander - wat
21:39 - Backmarker - wat
21:39 - Klon - wat
User avatar
Klon
 
Posts: 4144
Joined: 29 Mar 2009, 03:07
Location: Flensburg, Schleswig-Holstein

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby FullMetalJack » 31 Jul 2011, 01:43

Cars actually breaking down.
Collisions.
Cars being parked at the side of the road.
Wet races being started under the normal procedure.
Williams being a frontrunning team.
Kimi Raikkonen.
Independent teams (Williams is the only one left).
James Hunt's commentary (although Brundle will always be a legend).
Listen! Listen! I'm doing him an egg! You're not me and you paris! I'm sanding into your dumb redneck ass! - Scott Steiner
User avatar
FullMetalJack
 
Posts: 4602
Joined: 01 Apr 2009, 01:32
Location: Dunkin Donuts, Obesity

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby midgrid » 06 Aug 2011, 01:58

Whis wrote:
midgrid wrote:Parmalat as a sponsor.


the Parmalat that robbed money from thousands of italians? ;)


The very same, but I thought it looked good on an F1 car. :P

I thought of another one - teams using different-coloured bodywork to distinguish their drivers. Watching qualifying for the 1997 Monaco Grand Prix, we have: Prost - Panis (blue cockpit surround), Nakano (yellow cockpit surround); Ferrari - Irvine (yellow flashes on front wing); Tyrrell - Salo (orange X-wings), Verstappen (yellow X-wings), and no doubt other examples as well. Now it's boringly homogenised with the red/yellow T-cams.
"One day Bruno told me that he had heard the engine momentarily making a strange sound; his suspicion was that all the cylinders had been operating."
--Nigel Roebuck
User avatar
midgrid
 
Posts: 585
Joined: 03 Apr 2009, 05:27
Location: UK

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby DOSBoot » 06 Aug 2011, 02:02

When someone could have a number on their car without ranking. Tyrrell used 3, and 4. Williams used 5, and 6. Brabham used 7, and 8. Lotus used 11, and 12. Ligier used 25, and 26. Ferrari used 27, and 28. Why doesn't F1 allow that anymore?
Proud supporter of the United States 2nd Amendment.

2012 Perdicament Perdictions Champion.
User avatar
DOSBoot
 
Posts: 1088
Joined: 27 Dec 2010, 05:09
Location: Pensacola, Florida. United States.

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby FullMetalJack » 07 Aug 2011, 01:27

DOSBoot wrote:When someone could have a number on their car without ranking. Tyrrell used 3, and 4. Williams used 5, and 6. Brabham used 7, and 8. Lotus used 11, and 12. Ligier used 25, and 26. Ferrari used 27, and 28. Why doesn't F1 allow that anymore?


That would work IMO:

Red Bull
1. S Vettel
2. M Webber

Mercedes
3. M Schumacher
4. N Rosberg

Williams
5. R Barrichello
6. P Maldonado

McLaren
7. L Hamilton
8. J Button

Lotus
11. H Kovalainen
12. J Trulli

Force India
14. R Barrichello
15. P Di Resta

Renault
19. N Heidfeld
20. V Petrov

Hispania
21. D Ricciardo
22. V Liuzzi

Toro Rosso
23. S Buemi
24. J Alguersuari

Ferrari
27. F Alonso
28. F Massa

Sauber
29. K Kobayashi
30. S Perez

Virgin
31. T Glock
32. J D'Ambrosio

HRT get 21 and 22 because they used to be supplied by Dallara who had 21 and 22
Virgin use 31 and 32 which Simtek used in 1994
Listen! Listen! I'm doing him an egg! You're not me and you paris! I'm sanding into your dumb redneck ass! - Scott Steiner
User avatar
FullMetalJack
 
Posts: 4602
Joined: 01 Apr 2009, 01:32
Location: Dunkin Donuts, Obesity

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby mario » 07 Aug 2011, 07:05

DOSBoot wrote:When someone could have a number on their car without ranking. Tyrrell used 3, and 4. Williams used 5, and 6. Brabham used 7, and 8. Lotus used 11, and 12. Ligier used 25, and 26. Ferrari used 27, and 28. Why doesn't F1 allow that anymore?

Was it not the case, though, that even in those days some of the teams would use different numbers? What numbers would McLaren use, for example - they've had 5 and 6, 7 and 8 and 11 and 12 on their cars at various points in their history. Brabham, too, originally had No. 5 and 6 when McLaren had 7 and 8, and only switched to those numbers later.

Also, Ferrari, although perhaps synonymous with 27 and 28 these days, have a strong link with 11 and 12 (Lauda bore No. 12 when he won his first title with Ferrari, for example) - I don't think that it was until the 1980's that Ferrari were allocated No. 27 and 28, as originally No. 27 was allocated to Ligier (they had 26 and 27), and for a while Williams also ran under the numbers of 27 and 28.

Besides, under that system, what numbers should Renault use? The historic numbers that Renault had were 15 and 16, but equally you could say that they should use No. 19 and 20 from the Benetton era (as the current team was formed from a direct buyout of Benetton), which in turn came from Toleman.
Martin Brundle, on watching a replay of Grosjean spinning:
"The problem with Grosjean is that he want to take a look back at the corner he's just exited"
User avatar
mario
Moderator
 
Posts: 4495
Joined: 01 Nov 2009, 03:13

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Wizzie » 07 Aug 2011, 17:50

midgrid wrote:
Whis wrote:
midgrid wrote:Parmalat as a sponsor.


the Parmalat that robbed money from thousands of italians? ;)


The very same, but I thought it looked good on an F1 car. :P

I thought of another one - teams using different-coloured bodywork to distinguish their drivers. Watching qualifying for the 1997 Monaco Grand Prix, we have: Prost - Panis (blue cockpit surround), Nakano (yellow cockpit surround); Ferrari - Irvine (yellow flashes on front wing); Tyrrell - Salo (orange X-wings), Verstappen (yellow X-wings), and no doubt other examples as well. Now it's boringly homogenised with the red/yellow T-cams.


Don't forget all the years where Sauber ran red and yellow wing mirrors to distinguish the drivers.
Martin Brundle, at the 2005 San Marino GP wrote:You can sort of imagine in four or five years time talking about these guys we've got on the front two rows of the grid today, can't you? They're very much the future of Grand Prix Racing.
User avatar
Wizzie
 
Posts: 11817
Joined: 01 Apr 2009, 14:42
Location: The OTHER edge of the hole that is Penrith

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby James1978 » 07 Aug 2011, 18:52

I'd personally prefer Renault to have 15 and 16, and Force India to have 32 and 33, but then where would that leave Virgin?

Ligier never had #27 either, when they only had one car it was #26, then added #25 in 1979 when they started to run a 2nd car.

I'd say the numbers McLaren were most synonymous with when they didn't have 1 and 2, were actually 7 and 8.
"If you don't stop pointing your finger at me, I'll snap it off and shove it up your arse". :) (David Purley to Niki Lauda, 1977)
James1978
 
Posts: 2012
Joined: 27 Jul 2010, 04:46
Location: Darlington, NE England

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby mario » 07 Aug 2011, 19:38

James1978 wrote:I'd personally prefer Renault to have 15 and 16, and Force India to have 32 and 33, but then where would that leave Virgin?

Ligier never had #27 either, when they only had one car it was #26, then added #25 in 1979 when they started to run a 2nd car.

I'd say the numbers McLaren were most synonymous with when they didn't have 1 and 2, were actually 7 and 8.

Jarier raced for Ligier on a one off basis in 1977 at the Japanese Grand Prix (his race lasted for just three laps before his engine failed), and for that race he was allocated No. 27:
Image

You're right, though, that from 1979 onwards, when they raced two cars on a regular basis, that Ligier were then allocated 25 and 26.

As for Virgin Racing, well, on principal I guess that they'd have to be allocated new numbers as they do not have any link with a historic team, and the same case could be made for HRT too.
Martin Brundle, on watching a replay of Grosjean spinning:
"The problem with Grosjean is that he want to take a look back at the corner he's just exited"
User avatar
mario
Moderator
 
Posts: 4495
Joined: 01 Nov 2009, 03:13

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby RainierSassetti » 08 Aug 2011, 08:02

mario wrote:Jarier raced for Ligier on a one off basis in 1977 at the Japanese Grand Prix (his race lasted for just three laps before his engine failed), and for that race he was allocated No. 27:
Image

You're right, though, that from 1979 onwards, when they raced two cars on a regular basis, that Ligier were then allocated 25 and 26.

As for Virgin Racing, well, on principal I guess that they'd have to be allocated new numbers as they do not have any link with a historic team, and the same case could be made for HRT too.


I endorse team numbers more than one driver-one number. Less confusion about the numbers that change every year would be awesome, kinda like the TV numbers on sport jerseys. I dont wanna spend 10 minutes wondering "Dude, what is that car number?".
RainierSassetti
 
Posts: 21
Joined: 19 Apr 2011, 15:02

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Vepe » 08 Aug 2011, 10:02

To continue this car number system thingy, I did this:

1996
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
Tyrell: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
McLaren: 7,8
Footwork: 9,10
Jordan: 14,15
Forti: 21,22
Minardi: 23,24
Ligier: 25,26
Benetton: 27,28
Sauber: 29,30


1997
Code: Select all
Arrows: 1,2
Tyrell: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
McLaren: 7,8
Ferrari: 9,10
Jordan: 14,15
Minardi: 16,17
Prost: 18,19
Benetton: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Stewart: 25,26
Lola: 27,28


1998
Code: Select all
Williams: 1,2
Tyrell: 3,4
Arrows: 5,6
McLaren: 7,8
Ferrari: 9,10
Jordan: 11,12
Minardi: 14,15
Prost: 18,19
Benetton: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Stewart: 25,26


1999
Code: Select all
McLaren: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Arrows: 5,6
Williams: 7,8
Ferrari: 9,10
Jordan: 11,12
Minardi: 14,15
Prost: 18,19
Benetton: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Stewart: 25,26


2000
Code: Select all
McLaren: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Arrows: 5,6
Williams: 7,8
Ferrari: 9,10
Jordan: 11,12
Minardi: 14,15
Prost: 18,19
Benetton: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Jaguar: 25,26


2001
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Arrows: 5,6
Williams: 7,8
McLaren: 9,10
Jordan: 11,12
Minardi: 14,5
Prost: 18,19
Benetton: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Jaguar: 25,26


2002
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Arrows: 5,6
Williams: 7,8
McLaren: 9,10
Jordan: 11,12
Minardi: 14,15
Renault: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Jaguar: 25,26
Toyota: 27,28


2003
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Williams: 7,8
McLaren: 9,10
Jordan: 11,12
Minardi: 14,15
Renault: 20,21
Sauber: 22,23
Jaguar: 25,26
Toyota: 27,28


2004
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
McLaren: 7,8
Jordan: 9,10
Minardi: 11,12
Renault: 14,15
Sauber: 16,17
Jaguar: 18,19
Toyota: 20,21


2005
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
BAR: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
McLaren: 7,8
Jordan: 9,10
Minardi: 11,12
Renault: 14,15
Sauber: 16,17
Red Bull: 18,19
Toyota: 20,21


2006
Code: Select all
Renault: 1,2
Honda: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
McLaren: 7,8
Midland: 9,10
Toro Rosso: 11,12
Ferrari: 14,15
BMW Sauber: 16,17
Red Bull: 18,19
Toyota: 20,21
Super Aguri: 22,23


2007
Code: Select all
McLaren: 1,2
Honda: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
Renault: 7,8
Spyker: 9,10
Toro Rosso: 11,12
Ferrari: 14,15
BMW Sauber: 16,17
Red Bull: 18,19
Toyota: 20,21
Super Aguri: 22,23


2008
Code: Select all
Ferrari: 1,2
Honda: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
Renault: 7,8
Force India: 9,10
Toro Rosso: 11,12
McLaren: 14,15
BMW Sauber: 16,17
Red Bull: 18,19
Toyota: 20,21
Super Aguri: 22,23


2009
Code: Select all
McLaren: 1,2
Brawn: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
Renault: 7,8
Force India: 9,10
Toro Rosso: 11,12
Ferrari: 14,15
BMW Sauber: 16,17
Red Bull: 18,19
Toyota: 20,21


2010
Code: Select all
McLaren: 1,2
Mercedes: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
Renault: 7,8
Force India: 9,10
Toro Rosso: 11,12
Ferrari: 14,15
BMW Sauber: 16,17
Red Bull: 18,19
HRT: 20,21
Lotus: 22,23
Virgin: 25,26


2011
Code: Select all
Red Bull: 1,2
Mercedes: 3,4
Williams: 5,6
Renault: 7,8
Force India: 9,10
Toro Rosso: 11,12
Ferrari: 14,15
Sauber: 16,17
McLaren: 18,19
HRT: 20,21
Lotus: 22,23
Virgin: 25,26
Vepe
 
Posts: 298
Joined: 21 Dec 2010, 03:18
Location: Vantaa, Finland

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby James1978 » 08 Aug 2011, 21:15

RainierSassetti wrote:
mario wrote:Jarier raced for Ligier on a one off basis in 1977 at the Japanese Grand Prix (his race lasted for just three laps before his engine failed), and for that race he was allocated No. 27:
Image

You're right, though, that from 1979 onwards, when they raced two cars on a regular basis, that Ligier were then allocated 25 and 26.

As for Virgin Racing, well, on principal I guess that they'd have to be allocated new numbers as they do not have any link with a historic team, and the same case could be made for HRT too.


I endorse team numbers more than one driver-one number. Less confusion about the numbers that change every year would be awesome, kinda like the TV numbers on sport jerseys. I dont wanna spend 10 minutes wondering "Dude, what is that car number?".


The other thing about that is on some cars you can't even see the numbers - I mean where are the numbers on this year's Force India cars? Same goes for the JPM/Ralf era Williamses, I'm sure there are others too.
"If you don't stop pointing your finger at me, I'll snap it off and shove it up your arse". :) (David Purley to Niki Lauda, 1977)
James1978
 
Posts: 2012
Joined: 27 Jul 2010, 04:46
Location: Darlington, NE England

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby FullMetalJack » 08 Aug 2011, 22:17

James1978 wrote:The other thing about that is on some cars you can't even see the numbers - I mean where are the numbers on this year's Force India cars? Same goes for the JPM/Ralf era Williamses, I'm sure there are others too.


I think on the front wing on the Walrus car. Thanks for giving me another thing I miss.

The Williams BMW combination.
Listen! Listen! I'm doing him an egg! You're not me and you paris! I'm sanding into your dumb redneck ass! - Scott Steiner
User avatar
FullMetalJack
 
Posts: 4602
Joined: 01 Apr 2009, 01:32
Location: Dunkin Donuts, Obesity

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Phoenix » 09 Aug 2011, 04:46

Klon wrote:
dr-baker wrote:Dropped scores - is this the answer to today's super-reliability and risk-aversion? The 1950s had best 4 from 8 results, or best 5 from 9. So now, we would best 10 from 19 (pro rata). Although this might mean that Vettel would get a near-perfect score this year, it would not matter if you extract a bit more reliability from the car, because if you blow up, you simply reign it in a bit for the next race and know that it would go towards a dropped score. Equally, if you're Lewis Hamilton, you might not worry quite so much from a grid penalty, if it does not lead to one of your best 10 results of the year.

I bet someone can see a flaw in this somewhere...


Heeere! Teams wouldn't go with a risky approach, they would try to seal the title as soon as they could with their super reliable cars and by not throwing points away. Especially in a year like this that would merely lead to everyone doing their stuff until Hungary and then we would see an artificial entertainment program. Although that might lead to most top teams using their test drivers which would be neat as well...
Forget my objections, let's do this.


Oh, your issue is simple to solve - let's do like in 1979 and 1980. If the season is going to have 20 races, we split the season in two halves, and the 7 best results from each half count for the championship. You know what, if there was a historical moment for F1 to have such scoring system, this is certainly now, not 20 or more years ago when dropped results were actually a rare occurence.
Y O S O Y C O L C H O N E R O

thehemogoblin, on giving a reason for reporting a particular post wrote:He Zsolted!!!
User avatar
Phoenix
Moderator
 
Posts: 7385
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 23:58

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby the Masked Lapwing » 09 Aug 2011, 11:03

Rebadged engines. It gave the illusion of many suppliers.
Mark Beretta wrote:So is it true that you've converted about 200 grand worth of race car parts into about $1500?
Garry Rogers wrote:Well, we actually got $1900 cash, plus GST! This is a legitimate sale!
User avatar
the Masked Lapwing
 
Posts: 3447
Joined: 10 Sep 2010, 19:38
Location: Oran Park Raceway

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Phoenix » 10 Aug 2011, 08:44

the Masked Lapwing wrote:Rebadged engines. It gave the illusion of many suppliers.


Playlife FTW.
Y O S O Y C O L C H O N E R O

thehemogoblin, on giving a reason for reporting a particular post wrote:He Zsolted!!!
User avatar
Phoenix
Moderator
 
Posts: 7385
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 23:58

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby stupot94 » 12 Aug 2011, 00:22

Phoenix wrote:
the Masked Lapwing wrote:Rebadged engines. It gave the illusion of many suppliers.


Playlife FTW.



ACER!!!!
Say your prayers, here comes the Pastor
User avatar
stupot94
 
Posts: 469
Joined: 28 Feb 2011, 07:12
Location: Redditch

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby stupot94 » 12 Aug 2011, 00:24

Well I miss

Minardi
Drivers carrying flags when they win. (So many great images of this)
Murray Walker
Tyre Wars
Bahrain not being on the calender
Magny Cours
Williams domination
Taki Inoue making every weekend exciting
Takuma Sato
Any Japanese driver
Say your prayers, here comes the Pastor
User avatar
stupot94
 
Posts: 469
Joined: 28 Feb 2011, 07:12
Location: Redditch

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Sunshine_Baby_[IT] » 03 Feb 2012, 07:49

DOSBoot wrote:The sparks that came out of back of the cars during the 1980's, and early 1990's. Sure, you still see it sometimes in Singapore, but it's nowhere near where it used to be. :(

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Od1UX0JKV4

Sparks are one of the things I miss the most about F1...

It could seem a stupid thing, but I miss McLaren's Marlboro livery and number 27 on Ferrari too. :-)
I'm Perry McCarthy and Taki Inoue's fan number 1 and I always will be.

My twitter: @Miluuu_Sunshine
User avatar
Sunshine_Baby_[IT]
 
Posts: 1071
Joined: 27 Nov 2011, 01:17
Location: Bologna (Italy)

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby FullMetalJack » 03 Feb 2012, 07:57

A1 Ring
Listen! Listen! I'm doing him an egg! You're not me and you paris! I'm sanding into your dumb redneck ass! - Scott Steiner
User avatar
FullMetalJack
 
Posts: 4602
Joined: 01 Apr 2009, 01:32
Location: Dunkin Donuts, Obesity

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby eurobrun » 03 Feb 2012, 08:00

Sunshine_Baby_[IT] wrote:
DOSBoot wrote:The sparks that came out of back of the cars during the 1980's, and early 1990's. Sure, you still see it sometimes in Singapore, but it's nowhere near where it used to be. :(

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Od1UX0JKV4

Sparks are one of the things I miss the most about F1...

It could seem a stupid thing, but I miss McLaren's Marlboro livery and number 27 on Ferrari too. :-)


I was too young to see these live but judging by the old races i've seen on youtube I agree with you
Wizzie wrote:
Me wrote:I have no idea why I always think Tony D'Alberto is a mafia member :P
He's from a family of used cars salesmen... which might as well be the mafia Eurobrun :lol:
User avatar
eurobrun
 
Posts: 5790
Joined: 27 Oct 2011, 18:21
Location: Death > Janoskians

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby AdrianSutil » 03 Feb 2012, 09:19

Adrian Sutil.

Seriously, I'm not expecting him to return for a year or two if he's lucky :(
For explanation on recent inactivity, please read 2nd post on 2nd page of 'just nipping out' thread. Thank you.
User avatar
AdrianSutil
 
Posts: 3182
Joined: 08 Jun 2011, 11:21
Location: Folkestone, Kent

Re: Things you miss about F1...

Postby Sunshine_Baby_[IT] » 03 Feb 2012, 23:07

I miss Rubens Barrichello.
And Alex Zanardi too.
I'm Perry McCarthy and Taki Inoue's fan number 1 and I always will be.

My twitter: @Miluuu_Sunshine
User avatar
Sunshine_Baby_[IT]
 
Posts: 1071
Joined: 27 Nov 2011, 01:17
Location: Bologna (Italy)

Previous

Return to The Eric van de Poele Memorial Forum

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: dr-baker, pi314159 and 8 guests